He plays against some of the worst lacrosse teams on LI. Great player but he wouldn't have a quarter of his points playing in the real division in Suffolk.
That's why you would never make him an AA this year and you wait and see how he does in a few years when he is playing Varsity at St Anthonys . Even then you have to see how the kids do in the big games and not the games against HT and Kellenberg and St Doms. Those games will be stat padding