As a native to the north fork, it seems like Mattituck players are pretty good and all around know how to play the sport, but head coach is a real jerk; doesn't play kids equally at the Varsity level, doesn't give a lot of compliments to kids, shows up a late to practice on a regular basis, things like that. I also heard he NEVER played Girls Lacrosse when he was in high school, that is ridiculous!
But it is true there are no Greenport kids at the jv or varsity level YET, they didn't exclude anyone. Class D is weak right now definitely, but our local paper explained they played in league C during the regular season, and class C used to be the same thing, 3 teams made playoffs, 1st seed got a bye to the county final (SWR, then Sinai for years).