What is wrong with you NY parents???? In almost all other states the cut-off for entering Kindergarten is 8/31 (or 9/1) so if you kid is not 5 by 8/31 or 9/1, they are NOT ALLOWED to start K. That does NOT make a player will a fall birthday a CHEATER. No idea why NY has a school cut-off of 12/31. This is the problem. Not the other states... Get a grip

Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
The Madlax player is 2018 with a fall 1999 birthday. He has not been held back and does not play down, but he is very big. I'm not a fan of the grade based system, but calling a team or a particular kid a cheater based on your uninformed assessment of an online photograph is offensive.


glad someone who knows the kid could set the record straight. there are many valid arguments for age vs grade. But making false assumptions and exaggerating to make your points cheapens the argument and comes across as whining.


A fall 1999 birthday is 2017 in ny. So who screams cheater????