Chaminade would win. Still hard to match up a private vs public school. It's not fair. Chaminade is like an allstar team where public school you have to play what goes through the system.
Really? Then how did they lose to Yorktown? Had they played WM for a "true NYS Championship" it would not have gone well for the Flyers... Not this year.
Didn't the Hill Academy destroy Chaminade in an exhibition game this year? Chaminade is good but totally overrated. Far from the best team in NY (certainly not the best on LI), and probably would not do that well against the top MD area teams either.
