I think West Islip may lose 5-6 games this year. I don't think they have lost more than two a season in over ten years.
It is a combination of WI being a little down and a lot of other teams have closed the gap, instead of just one team a year challenging them (usually WM) now 6-7 teams can play with them. WI is still an unbelievable story over the last 10 years. I believe the below is correct
'05 19-2 '06 23-0 State Champs '07 22-1 State Champs '08 19-2 '09 22-1 State Champs '10 21-1 State Champs '11 19-1 '12 21-1 State Champs