Agreed. It's black and white. He is either in 3rd grade or he is not. Only grey area would be if he is in 3rd grade but on a different GC team and played with this GC team this day because they needed a goalie. Then I would say GC coaches should have asked FS coaches but it's not nearly as bad since he would at least be the same age. GC coaches need to clear this up - WITHOUT mentioning names.