Originally Posted by adhrf20
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Pull the goalie for an extra attacker that must stay on the defensive side of the field. Now how does that make any sense?


Obviously the extra attacker wouldnt stay on the defensive side of the field. There would have to be a slight rule change regarding offsides on a delayed penalty. I get what Redyeh is saying. Its actually an interesting idea


It's not interesting. It's offsides and the benefit of being man up comes after they lose the ball.


You do get that with a rule such as proposed would likely come with a corresponding change that makes it not offsides?!

Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
1) make the Sphere 12 inches not 7 inches. Coaches are now telling players to cradle in Sphere.( I have heard a big club use the terminology keep in the window).Refs need to understand you can't have 300 checks in Sphere in a game and zero cradling sphere. Also uncheckable stick. Watch a man college
games, many players tuck stick and lean over it when going to cage inside. Immediately it is uncheckable and turnover, there is no 3 seconds here in how long...it is immediate. Because then they pop up and shoot.g

2) on a ground ball between two players below the knees there is no empty stick check. I love in girls lax how we reward
The ball to the girls who missed the ground ball. The girl times a great check and because the girl missed it she get s ball. Not a good lesson.

3) get rid of draw, let's play. The ball placement in a stick,the fact
That many refs don't know rule on draw(mainly sticks need to be straight up-not leaning back), and the biggest volition never called which is easy-no part of the stick can be below waist. I don't want every call made but when the butt end is at players thigh or knee it is illegal, and huge advantage. This is such and easy call that they refuse to make- which tells me they don't know the rule. Also no empty stick check on draw-go get it and make it 50/50 ball.

Like they did in basketball take the human element out
of it(one jump ball to start game). In boys at least they do not have sticks touching which has help, and ball is placed on ground evenly away from sticks-still not perfect by far.

As we know in girls the draw is HUGE In outcome of game.

In short I do feel for the refs with a game that rules are so subjective-not an easy job at all.

Have a great rest of summer.


Great suggestions. My daughter drops her stick when the refs purposefully put the ball in the pocket of her opponent on the draw and then refuse to change it.

I would also like to see the goal count when shooting space is violated. The goal should count and possession should also go back to that same team. More like basketball. Too many times I have seen 1 goal games decided by a free possession shot where a goal is taken back, then the girls misses the open net.


I was with you until the shooting space "let the goal count"; It is a dangerous shot then!


If nobody gets hurt, it's not a dangerous shot. It's too subjective to say that. Refs decide game.



NO, ITS NOT, THAT IS NOT THE RULE. A DANGEROUS SHOT DOES NOT HAVE TO MAKE CONTACT. UNLESS THE RULES CHANGED.

LISTEN HALF THE SHOTS TAKEN ARE NOT LEGAL SHOTS. AND I AM AN OFFENSIVE MINDED COACH


Stop whining, the object of the game is to score without touching anyone. Let the girls play. Way too many whistles. I'm starting to think I have to teach my daughter to be a flopper.



Please dont berate me I am asking a serious question.
If I rarely see a shooting space call without the shot. If the girl doesn't make the dangerous shot it seems that there is no foul.How often is the dangerous shot called? I often see goals pulled off the board for shooting space. Why wouldn't the and one like in basketball work. It would certainly make the avoidance of shooting space a priority if the goal counted and then had a free shot