US Lacrosse Community Forum Forums NORTHEAST LACROSSE BOTC MAIN FORUM (LI, CT, WC) CHAMINADE Lacrosse. Stories and news.

Who says your kid won't get bitched by the hold back? Pretty bold statement. I don't agree with the hold backs, but you're such an a hole I actually hope your kid gets his helmet turned around. Live and let live jealous petty jerk.

Not happening here, its your holdback that went home crying cause he's a failure. Remember, you put him there ! Cheating [lacrosse]

Why is this soap opera discussion of holdbacks playing out on the Chammy thread? Can we please come to our senses and get back to unfairly bashing the elitist Chammy blowhards? Let's stay on topic here!!!!!

I thought this was the LI public High School Football scoreboard thread. I'm waiting for the score alerts.

If you could read dope you would see I wrote I don't agree with it. Therefore don't have one. But you're a jealous [lacrosse], loser. You're on a lax site sobbing about fairness. Get a grip guy who never played. Whaa whaa it's not fair, you're a [lacrosse]. How bout them apples!

Me thinks the under tone is directed towards chaminade's latest practice of accepting high profile holdbacks. And how a good portion of the elitist (your words not mine) did the pre first hold back to give little Johnny the upper hand.

games start tomorrow scores to follow

any good games tomorrow

Now back to the regularly scheduled posts.

The early holdback (pre-1st grade or kindergarten) thing happens in public schools as well and has happened since at least the 90s, especially in our more well-to-do towns. Back when I played, Garden City's team always had a few kids who were basically a year older than everyone else, with some graduating at 19 or very close to it. They bought beer without any worries a year before everyone else could once we all got to college (I didn't realize that holdbacks were even a thing until I got to college). Though nothing beats the hockey guys, who always had at least one freshman that was 21-22 (anyone who played at an Ivy or NE school can vouch for me here).

All of that said, I'm still very disappointed that Chaminade appears to be involved in this holdback bullsh*t. The whole "repeating 8th grade" thing is definitely not something that we can all be proud of, and as such should really be looked at.

Anyone in this thread a current parent? Is it really this prevalent, or just the usual smack-talking of parents from other towns/schools?

The above post about GC hold backs is a LIE! never happened. But hey throw anything out there enough times and it becomes the truth. Tool

What do you mean "appears to be involved?" A kid takes the test, scores well and gets in. Jack Moran isn't conspiring to bring in holdbacks

In the current Freshman class at Chaminade there is one re-classified kid who is verbally committed to a D1 school. That is the only one that I know of.

How old is he

19

it is not a lie about GC.

Yes, he should be in 10th, not 9th. He started school late as a little boy and would not make the 9/1 cut off date if tournaments and Pal had ever adopted and enforced that rule in his youth. Water under the bridge now, he won.

What team is he on? For club.

Yes it is a LIE about GC. Pretty easy to make up a story while remaining anonymous and not having to provide any facts at all. Put your name behind it, and provide the names of the hold backs. Then let's see. Otherwise I call you a LIAR and your story a LIE. Adios, Pinocchio.

I think you're all confusing two players. There's a holdback/reclass senior from GC that went to friends and there is a holdback/reclass freshman from From a different town that repeated 8th grade at LuHi. It's kind of creepy at the youth level. I can see doing a PG after high school but at the younger levels it just seems like sending the wrong message to the kid.

The original poster (liar) stated this occurred in the 90's. So I am not confused, but he is a LIAR!

The GC / Chaminade old for the grade kid plays for express

What about those in the Soph class. How many 2000 birthdays there. And Im not talking december babies either. While we are at it how about the jr class.


And how are those grades, you really didnt need the help for grades or adjusting did you. The truth will set you free, actually it wont it will get just get you rediculed.

Freshman holdback is not from GC.

LIE, of course. Now is there a Cham connection?

The prior post say he is GC kid at Chaminade who also plays on LIE . . . !!

player in question at chaminade is from a different town

Not my kid, not my business, not in my control, not my problem.

It was a lie, liar poster never responded to his lies, because he's a lying sack of you know what. But make up a lie like that liar and the lies will become truths. It's political campaigning at its best. Liars lie and he lied and now the little liar won't respond because he's a liar!

...and now the poor kid gets hurt. Feel bad for him, Dopey coaches go to the well one too many times and the young man pays the price. One kid cannot play every position on this or any team. Great job!

Teeeible move by the coaches and now it cost the player. It's not right.

Why did the situation cost the player

Of course coaches are going to go to a stud holdback. Parents fault all the way.

What happened ?

How bad is the boy hurt

Funny how when someone on BOTC is called out for lying they go silent!

Who is lying about what? You sound like a crazy person.

How bad was the boy hurt. I hope not serious

another win for lindy 19-13 8-0 baby

Go back and read, I'm not crazy, I just see and hear things you can't. Jealous?