Originally Posted by Anonymous
pretty sure hawks only had four, one of the bethesda area teams had 7 and madlax had 6, so it's not strictly a crabs thing, i have had two sons play in the npyll who were not heldback, most people in this area have moved on and don't whine about it everyday

Convenient, if it was true, but it is not even close to reality. Would make Crabs seem almost normal. Make stuff up much? Crabs are the heart of the reclass issue, and it's not normal.

Crabs and Hawks over ruled other members and voted to take NPYLL grade based. They did it to protect themselves, and maintain recruiting edge.

That's a fact!


How is it an Edge when everyone has the same rules?

Most teams have hold backs for either intentional sports reasons or unintentional education/developmental reasons.

The single grade method is far better than the two year age cutoff combined method, so there is progress.