As I read the posts why is it anyone with an opinion against early commits is jealous? There is a reality that they could be rescinded. But, it's hard to imagine anyone turning them down. I certainly wouldn't. You offered my son a college commitment at a school he wants he will say yes the same way he will to a new car when he hits age 17. What kid wouldn't and what parent wouldn't be proud and happy to get that financial support. It is controversial.