When we ( the wife, son and I ) started looking at Catholic high schools it was explained to us simply If you want academics and sports go to Chaminade If you want academics and girls go to Kellenberg If you want sports and girls go to St Anthonys
Sounds like a Nade parent with an inferiority complex. St Anthony parents wouldn't stoop to such a low level.
Bottom line: St Anthonys is not good acaedmically. You may have smart kids attending but they are stifeled by the inferior curriculum and quaily of teaching. You go to SA for sports!