So far it looks like West Islip is the town with the most kids who have gone on to be the "best of the best" at the D1 level.
5 D-1 All Americans
5 D-1 All Conference
1 North South Game
All in recent years.
Come on, I know that some of the other towns have also produced some top players. Garden City, Huntington, Manhasset, Syosset, Massapequa, Farmingdale ???