Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
Originally Posted by Anonymous
I am waiting for the spin police or spiniot to tell us the top 20 high school player that SBU got coming out of high school while FL, UNC, Maryland, ND get these players every year. Again not sure but has an Inside Lacrosse top 20 player ever selected to go to SBU.


All this does is prove the point, that the lists are not 100% spot on.



You can't have it both ways, either the list is accurate or it's not? We keep hearing that all the players on any given list are there because the evaluators and coaches who make the list can't all be wrong. Btw the Brown freshman awarded the best HS player in the country is #46 on IL list of incoming recruits, it would appear the somebody has to be wrong about the ranking, wouldn't it?


Here we go again.

To answer your question, No.

Nobody has ever come on here and said any list is "100% spot on". Every time this issue comes up it is brought up by someone trying to discredit the a list , an accolade, or a team while also trying to diminish the accomplishments.

Nobody says "they can't all be wrong". What has been stated is that: the large majority of players who are recruited by the top college programs, are listed by Inside Lacrosse as a Top 30 - 40 HS player, are selected as an Under Armour All-American etc... Do go on to have very successful college careers at many of the top programs.

Being the "Best" player is not the criteria for The U.S. Lacrosse National High School Player of The year Award.