Originally Posted by Anonymous
what an idiot. McDonalds all Americans are an all star team . what, do you think your h.s. team is some sort of national all star collection? how's that Chaminade kool aid taste?
Any NESCAC team would handle those two teams. even last place like Ct. college.


Nobody claimed a high school team would beat a NESCAC. NESCAC is top-to-bottom the strongest conference in D3. Last year's last place team (Colby) still ended up in the top 50 nationwide according to LP.

Originally Posted by Anonymous
Ok, mr Cortland - not 1 of their players even resemble the same athletes being recruited by ACC and IVY - this is not football (so the college physical maturity won't make up the difference)

Watch Chaminade/Anthony's this year... And you will immediately realize you are watching a much higher level lacrosse than Cortland...


If you knew anything about lacrosse (or played in high school or college) you wouldn't have named Cortland as a team that any high school team could beat.

But Chaminade in a good year (or Ward Melville, or Boys' Latin, or any other traditionally strong high school program) would almost certainly beat most D3 teams outside of the top ~100 or so (there are more than 200 D3 lacrosse programs).

(I'm the one who introduced the "high school vs. D3" topic.)