are you talking about a 16 yr old Chaminade freshman or is this off on a tangent?
16 yr old chaminade freshman
If so, if a player is infact a 16yo freshman he is no doubt a double hold back.
Defined as: took an advantage over his on age peers, twice. A late birthday (pre 1st) + a hold back (8th grade) = Double holdback took the advantage twice.
Now this can all be the $hit house rumor mill - but if it isnt, isnt there a rule in the catholic league against such a player playing Freshman ball of any sorts. Especially ones with contact.
A 13 year old boy does not expect to play against a 16 year old in Freshman sports. It does matter and is other peoples business. Had you said a player in this situation was on JV A or Varsity team Id say was another story.