I never considred doing this but you both make good points. I can tell you that I reflect on my life and there is little doubt that more maturity that only comes with age and life experiences would have done me good. The extra year would have helped academically, athletically, and perspetive. How many of us really knew what we wanted to do straight out of high school. I for one think a year off before going to college is a good idea as long as it doesn't turn into 5 years. Postgrad year? Also a good idea, a couple of top end recruits are doing that right now. Bubba the #1 ranked recruit in the country that just bumped Matt Moore is reclassing righ now with a PG year. Manown going to Duke is doing a PG year as well.
Should we start college when we are 18 or does 20 perhaps offer a better foundation. Are they cheating, no? Boys mature and develop more slowly and if it allows you to do better in the classroom and field while ultimately preparing you for the game of life....