Given the conversation I'd like to hear from the anti-holdback parents their view on the following and whether their sons root for/idolize this prolific player?

2007 HS Grad with lower level D1 commitment
Re-classed to 2008 via a PG year.
Stole a roster spot at a top Ivy program from a "deserving" 2008 HS Grad
Took a rare Ivy redshirt in 2012 stole a 2013 starting position from another deserving player

This is an example of a 2x re-class player. Many boys on LI have his poster on their wall.

Is this cheating?